Final Fantasy XII - A Beautiful World in Search of a Better Story
Final Fantasy XII occupies an unusual place in my relationship with the series. Released for the PlayStation 2 in 2006, it remains the highest-numbered mainline Final Fantasy game I have completed. I never got around to XIII, XV, or XVI, and I haven’t played either of the online entries, XI and XIV. In that sense, XII was my last complete experience with the direction Square Enix was taking its flagship series.
Recently, I attempted another playthrough. My impressions may have been influenced by watching Sebbywebz’s entertaining challenge in which he beats the game without using his hands, taking advantage of its automation. It reminded me of a familiar criticism: given a sufficiently refined set of Gambits, Final Fantasy XII can almost play itself.
There is truth to that, but the combat is not what most disappointed me. Even at the time, I thought the gameplay had some genuinely clever ideas. My problem was much more fundamental: I never cared very much about the story or most of the people in it. For a series that had given me so many memorable adventures, that was a difficult failing to overlook.
The Empire That Made Me Think of Final Fantasy VI
Before XII came out, I was particularly excited by its premise. Here was another Final Fantasy built around an expansionist empire conquering smaller nations, with occupied territories, resistance movements, military officers, and larger political ambitions. It sounded as though Square Enix might be revisiting some of what made Final Fantasy VI so compelling.
In VI, the Gestahlian Empire is not merely a backdrop. Its actions reshape the characters’ lives, its cruelty is impossible to ignore, and the conflict keeps escalating in unexpected ways. Kefka, in particular, becomes increasingly unforgettable. I hoped that the Archadian Empire in XII, with its imposing Judges, airships, and conquest of Dalmasca, would provide the foundation for something similarly absorbing.
It certainly looked the part. But the narrative never had the same pull for me. XII spends a great deal of time on alliances, succession, resistance politics, and the competing interests of Archadia and Rozarria. None of those subjects are inherently boring; political drama can make for excellent fantasy. The issue is that I found the presentation dry and the emotional stakes strangely distant. There were plenty of events I understood intellectually, but relatively few I felt invested in.
Vayne Solidor should have been a fascinating antagonist. He is an ambitious imperial leader with a political vision, not simply a madman bent on destruction. Yet he never struck me as especially intimidating, charismatic, or memorable. Compared with what VI managed with its villains and conflicts, XII felt surprisingly flat.
Nethicite, the Occuria, and a Story That Lost Me
The deeper the game goes into its mythology, the less interesting I found it. Much of the central conflict revolves around nethicite, an extraordinarily powerful substance, and the Occuria, near-immortal beings who have influenced the course of Ivalice’s history. One of their own, Venat, rebels against the others and supports Vayne and Dr. Cid in their efforts to free humanity from that control.
On paper, the idea has potential. Who should decide humanity’s future: remote, godlike beings manipulating history, or flawed human rulers who might abuse freedom once they obtain it? Princess Ashe’s temptation to use overwhelming power for revenge could have made that conflict very personal.
But in practice, I found the whole business tedious. The revelations about nethicite and the Occuria never gave me the sense of wonder, dread, or urgency that the better Final Fantasy stories have managed. Vayne’s struggle against divine interference might be philosophically interesting, but that does not automatically make it dramatically engaging. I was far more interested in seeing the next location than in finding out what the next revelation would be.
It is not that I object to gods, crystals, or supernatural manipulation in a Final Fantasy game. Those ideas are part of the series’ identity. My problem is with their execution here. The story keeps insisting that the fate of history is at stake, while seldom making me feel the weight of it.
Balthier and Fran Deserved a Better Adventure
The cast is another reason I struggled to connect with XII. Vaan is our initial point-of-view character, an orphan living under imperial occupation who dreams of becoming a sky pirate. His loss and resentment give him a plausible place in the setting, but once the political plot takes over, he often feels like a spectator to Ashe’s story. Penelo is pleasant enough, though she also has relatively little dramatic weight.
Ashe has the strongest claim to being the story’s emotional centre: her homeland has been conquered, her family torn apart, and she must decide whether revenge is worth the price. Basch has his own complicated history of loyalty and disgrace. These should have been compelling people to follow. For whatever reason, I simply did not find their journeys as moving as those of the casts in VI, VII, or IX.
The exceptions, for me, are Balthier and Fran. Balthier is the suave sky pirate who plays something like the traditional thief’s role: self-interested, witty, and considerably more entertaining than most of his companions. His personal connection to Dr. Cid also gives him a reason to be involved beyond merely tagging along. Fran, meanwhile, is a Viera, one of Ivalice’s rabbit-eared people, whose distinctive appearance, reserved personality, and separation from her own community make her intriguing.
They are also a wonderful pairing: an irreverent adventurer and his composed, capable partner. If I had to choose two characters whose adventures I would have preferred to follow, it would be them. Balthier even jokes that he is the leading man. I rather wish the game had taken him at his word.
A Combat System That Can Play Itself — By Design
One criticism of XII is that its Gambit system allows the player to automate much of the fighting. A Gambit is essentially an instruction with a condition and an action: heal an ally whose HP falls below a threshold, attack the party leader’s target, cure a status ailment, or revive a fallen companion. Arrange these instructions in the correct order, and your characters become remarkably self-sufficient.
Sebbywebz’s no-hands challenge is an amusing demonstration of how far the idea can be pushed. But I do not think that makes Gambits a bad mechanic. Building and refining a reliable set of instructions is itself a kind of strategy, almost like writing a small program. An encounter can be satisfying because your preparation worked, even if you issued few commands during the fight itself. And the player can still intervene manually when necessary.
More importantly, XII moved away from the abrupt transition into a separate battle screen. Enemies inhabit the areas you explore, and combat unfolds there rather than in an isolated arena. It was a substantial change from the older games, and one I generally liked. The combat sometimes risks becoming too passive, but it is flexible, distinctive, and more thoughtful than the jokes about playing with one hand suggest.
The License Board and the Pleasure of Exploration
The other system I remember enjoying is the License Board. Characters earn License Points and spend them on tiles that grant permission to use weapons, armour, spells, abilities, and other improvements. It gives progression a satisfying sense of direction: a few more battles might unlock the equipment or ability you have been working toward.
The original PS2 version did not have the distinct job boards familiar to players of The Zodiac Age. Everyone developed on the same broad board, meaning that characters could eventually become rather similar if you invested enough time. I can see that as a weakness in character identity, but the freedom to build and develop the party was still enjoyable. The later job-based versions changed that structure considerably, so my praise here is specifically for the game I played in 2006.
Where XII truly excels, though, is in the world around those systems. Ivalice is magnificent. Rabanastre feels like a proper city, with crowded streets and a bustling Muthru Bazaar that recalls the atmosphere of a great historic marketplace. Bhujerba, with its extraordinary position in the sky, is another highlight. The imperial grandeur of Archades, the vast deserts and sandseas, and places such as Eruyt Village make the world feel varied and inhabited.
There is a striking mix of architecture, cultures, and landscapes. Even on PlayStation 2 hardware, the designers made these locations feel expansive and distinctive. The sense of scale and the attention to detail are among the best things about the game. I often wanted to continue playing simply to discover what was beyond the next area, even when the story was giving me little incentive to care.
Clan Hunts and the Infamous Zodiac Spear
I also enjoyed the Clan Centurio setup and the monster hunts. Rather than every activity serving the main quest, you could accept contracts to track down dangerous marks, collect rewards, and test your party against increasingly difficult enemies. Montblanc and the clan gave Ivalice a pleasant sense of adventuring life beyond the imperial conflict. Some of the optional encounters could be extremely demanding, but that was part of their appeal.
Then there was the Zodiac Spear, one of the strangest equipment secrets I remember from the PS2 era. In the original release, it was possible to obtain this extremely powerful weapon from the Necrohol of Nabudis much earlier than its strength might suggest, provided you had not opened certain seemingly ordinary treasure chests elsewhere in the game.
There were four specific forbidden chest locations, including one outside Old Dalan’s house in Rabanastre’s Lowtown and a group of chests on the Phon Coast. Open even one of those linked treasures and the guaranteed Zodiac Spear chest in Nabudis would no longer be available. A player who liked opening everything could permanently miss the straightforward route to one of the game’s strongest weapons without realizing they had done anything wrong.
You could still try your luck in the Henne Mines, but the alternative chest had an overall one-in-a-thousand chance of giving you the spear. That is the sort of absurd item hunting that reminds me of chasing the Pink Tail from the rare Pink Puffs in Final Fantasy IV. There is something wonderfully old-fashioned about such a secret, although I cannot pretend the hidden, arbitrary requirements are good design. It is memorable partly because it is so unreasonable.
Music, Presentation, and the Tactics Connection
The graphics remain impressive for their time, and the art direction carries much of their appeal. The character designs, clothing, airships, cities, and architectural details give XII a visual identity unlike most other numbered entries. The soundtrack, led by Hitoshi Sakimoto, is also strong. Its orchestral, atmospheric approach suits a world preoccupied with empires, armies, and ancient powers. It is not necessarily filled with the same personally unforgettable melodies I associate with some earlier Final Fantasy games, but it complements the setting wonderfully.
There is also the connection to Yasumi Matsuno, whose work on Final Fantasy Tactics helped establish Ivalice. Matsuno originally led the development of XII before stepping back from his directing and producing roles in 2005, so it would be unfair to treat the finished game as exclusively his work or to blame its shortcomings on any single person.
I have never played the original Final Fantasy Tactics. Despite its reputation, I have generally struggled to get interested in tactical games where characters move across a battlefield like chess pieces. I did, however, play and enjoy Final Fantasy Tactics Advance for the Game Boy Advance. That is the one in which Marche and other children find themselves in a transformed fantasy world, and Judges oversee battles while enforcing laws that can prohibit particular actions, such as using certain weapons or types of magic. I remember finding those restrictions an entertaining twist.
So I can appreciate the appeal of Ivalice and the team behind it. Unfortunately, XII did not give me the emotional attachment that I hoped its pedigree would provide.
Final Thoughts — More Impressive Than Engaging
I understand why Final Fantasy XII has its admirers. It is ambitious, visually distinctive, mechanically inventive, and filled with places worth exploring. The Gambits, License Board, and hunts deserve genuine credit. It is also a historically important experiment in how a mainline Final Fantasy could handle continuous exploration and party combat, even if its particular legacy means relatively little to me personally.
Yet when I think back on the games I love most in this series, I remember their stories and characters before almost anything else. I remember the emotional weight of VI, the cast and revelations of VII, and the warmth and sense of adventure of IX. XII gave me grand cities, intriguing systems, and a conflict over who should control humanity’s destiny, but very few reasons to become attached to the people supposedly deciding that destiny.
There is a Nintendo DS sequel, Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings, which I have not played. Perhaps its greater emphasis on Vaan and his companions would leave a different impression, though its real-time strategy gameplay is quite a departure from the PS2 original.
For me, the verdict remains much the same as it was almost twenty years ago: Final Fantasy XII is a beautiful, well-built RPG that never quite convinced me its story was worth the journey. I can admire the world without loving the game.
Rating
Category Score Story 2/5 Characters 2/5 Combat and gameplay 4/5 Character progression / License Board 4/5 World and exploration 4.5/5 Graphics and art direction 4/5 Music 4/5 Historical significance (personal assessment) 1/5
Category average: 3.19/5 Overall personal rating: 3/5
An impressive world and clever combat systems cannot fully compensate for a story and cast that left me cold.